In other words, it means knowing how to find information thoughtfully, understanding where it came from and why it exists, and using it responsibly. You’ll also hear terms like media literacy and digital citizenship. They overlap, but media literacy focuses on analyzing messages, and digital citizenship focuses on how we behave online. Information literacy is the bigger umbrella that holds them together. It’s also a moving target. In September 2026, ACRL revised its framework for the first time in a decade, and questions about AI now run through nearly every part of it.
Check Your Shelf
Sign up to receive Check Your Shelf, the Librarian’s One-Stop Shop For News, Book Lists, And More.
Where to Start Teaching Information Literacy
Here’s the thing: students aren’t bad at evaluating sources because they’re lazy (or at least that’s not the only reason). They’re bad at it because they’re doing exactly what we taught them. Read closely. Check the “About” page. Look for a professional design and an official-sounding name. It’s easier to trust a .org, .edu, or .gov than .com. For years, I taught some version of that checklist myself. But anyone with a free afternoon and a website builder can make something look credible. The page itself is the last place to find out who’s really behind it.
So, fact-checkers do something that feels almost rebellious: they leave. They open a new tab and look up the source instead of reading it. It’s called lateral reading, and it flips the whole process. As researcher Sam Wineburg explains, the first question isn’t “is this true?” It’s “who is the person or the organization behind this claim?”
Its partner skill is click restraint. It means not clicking the first search result just because it’s first. Scroll. Scan. Pick the source that actually makes sense. Not the sponsored posts that are inevitably listed first.
And the best part? It works. In a study across six high schools in Lincoln, Nebraska, students who completed six 50-minute lessons on lateral reading got significantly better at judging sources. In Canada, a program called CTRL-F worked with more than 2,000 middle and high schoolers. Before the lessons, only 6% could spot an advocacy group’s agenda. Right after, 31% could. Six weeks later? 49%. The skill didn’t fade. It grew.
My favorite way to practice is a five-minute credibility challenge. I show students two sources that look equally polished and give them five minutes to figure out who’s behind each one. The only rule is that they can’t use the sites themselves. Watching their faces when a neutral-sounding “institute” turns out to be funded by the exact industry it’s defending? That’s the lesson. Them finding the information on their own sticks with them in a way me lecturing does not.
How Information Gets Made
Every piece of information was made by someone, somehow, for some reason. That sounds obvious, but it’s one of the hardest ideas for students to really absorb. A peer-reviewed study goes through months of research, editing, and expert review. A news article gets fact-checked and edited, usually on a deadline. A TikTok can go from someone’s brain to a million screens in under a minute. None of these formats is automatically good or bad, but knowing how something was made tells you a lot about how much to trust it. The ACRL calls this “Information Creation as a Process,” which is a very librarian way of saying: look at the recipe, not just the cake.
It also helps to give students words for what they’re seeing. “Fake news” has been used so loosely that it barely means anything anymore. Researchers Claire Wardle and Hossein Derakhshan offer something much more useful: seven types of misleading content. Some of it is satire that gets mistaken for news. Some is fabricated, completely made up and designed to deceive. Some is imposter content that borrows the name of a trusted outlet, or false connection, where the headline promises something the story doesn’t deliver. And some of the sneakiest types involve real material used dishonestly: misleading framing, false context, and manipulated content.
Those last two are where images come in. A real photo with the wrong caption, say a protest from five years ago labeled as happening yesterday, is false context. A doctored video is manipulated content. But images can mislead even when nobody lies. The ACRL’s visual literacy framework puts it bluntly: “Visuals are never neutral.” Someone chose the angle, the crop, the moment to click the shutter, and the caption underneath. A tight shot can make a small crowd look massive. A graph whose numbers start at 50 instead of zero can make a tiny difference look dramatic. Students tend to trust images more than words. (“I saw it with my own eyes!”) So this is one of the most important lessons we can teach.
A few ways to practice:
- Give students a stack of real viral posts and have them sort each one into Wardle and Derakhshan’s seven types. The debates over borderline cases are the best part.
- Show the same photo with two different captions and ask how each one changes what they think is happening.
- Teach reverse image search and let students trace a viral photo back to where it first appeared. Spoiler: it’s often older, or from somewhere else entirely.
Why AI Isn’t a Research Tool
When I was in school, teachers treated Wikipedia like contraband. Cite it, and you might as well have turned in a blank page. Somewhere along the way, though, librarians made peace with it, and for a good reason: Wikipedia shows its work. Every claim is supposed to have a citation. Every edit is public. There’s even a discussion page behind each article where editors argue, sometimes for years, over whether a sentence is accurate. It’s not a source you cite, but it can be a decent place to start, because it points you somewhere else.
AI chatbots don’t do any of that. You often can’t see where an answer came from, who checked it, or what got left out. You just get a confident, polished paragraph that sounds exactly like the truth whether it is or not. If Wikipedia is a starting point you have to verify, AI is a starting point you likely can’t even trace.
The ACRL’s 2026 framework is surprisingly blunt about this. It warns that AI tools aren’t inherently authoritative and can’t evaluate information on their own. It points to the “sycophantic nature of AI chatbots,” meaning their tendency to tell you what you want to hear, and notes that their answers can include “fabricated or hallucinated citations.” Translation: sources that look real but don’t exist. The framework also flags that AI gives homogenized answers that don’t reflect the full range of evidence, and that it carries real environmental and social costs.
But the warning that stops me in my tracks as a high school librarian is this one: reaching for AI early in the research process can weaken critical thinking and let the tool steer the research instead of the student. Teenagers are still building the skills we’re trying to teach. Handing them a shortcut before they’ve learned the long way around doesn’t save them time. It skips the learning entirely.
Pay Attention to Feelings, Not Just Facts
Here’s something I had to learn the hard way: smart people fall for misinformation all the time. Not because they’re careless, but because the content was designed to get past their brains and go straight for their feelings.
Think about the last post that made you furious, or scared, or smug in that “I knew it!” kind of way. Did you stop and check it? Most of us don’t. Strong emotions make us share faster and question less, especially when the post confirms something we already believe. That’s not an accident. The News Literacy Project points out that posts tapping into primal emotions spread farther and faster, because they keep people engaged. And researcher Claire Wardle, who helped define the seven types of misleading content, has warned that disinformation often works by playing on people’s emotions, so simply throwing more facts at the problem won’t fix it.
The ACRL’s 2026 framework now names this directly. It calls for teaching “the affective dimension of learning” (that’s academic-speak for feelings) alongside the thinking skills, so students understand how confirmation bias and emotional reactions shape what they believe. I love that this made it into the framework, because it’s the piece most checklists leave out. Students can know every fact-checking strategy in the book and still skip all of them when a post makes their blood boil.
So I teach students to treat a strong feeling as a signal. Not a sign that something is false, but a sign to slow down. When a post makes you feel something big, that’s exactly the moment to ask:
- How does this make me feel?
- Is it trying to make me feel this way?
- Do I want this to be true?
- Would I check this if it said the opposite?
That third question is the hardest, and it’s the one I ask myself most.
One simple activity: before discussing a viral post, have students write down a single word for how it made them feel. Then compare. Angry, scared, amused, validated. Talk about what in the post created that reaction. Was it a word choice? An image? A headline in all caps? Once students can see the emotional machinery, it loses some of its power.
Every Class is a Chance to Practice
I’ll be honest: I love teaching lateral reading. But if the only place students practice it is during their one library visit with their class, it won’t stick. Information literacy isn’t a unit you finish. It’s a habit, and habits need repetition in lots of places.
Researchers keep landing on the same point. Sam Wineburg warns against treating information literacy as a “patch” on top of the existing curriculum and argues that it needs to run through all of it. The good news is that this doesn’t require a brand-new course or a pile of extra lessons. The News Literacy Project found that teachers were far more likely to adopt short, drop-in lessons that fit inside what they were already teaching than a standalone unit that pushed something else out.
And every subject already has natural openings:
- Science: pull up a viral TikTok health claim and investigate it as a class. (Wineburg’s example is castor oil, which, yes, is apparently still a thing.)
- Social Studies: compare primary and secondary sources, or examine how two outlets cover the same event.
- English: dig into author’s purpose and bias, skills English teachers already teach, applied to an influencer’s post instead of an essay.
- Math: analyze misleading graphs.
- Art: talk about how images are cropped, edited, and framed.
The magic happens when students hear the same questions everywhere. “Who’s behind this?” in the library. “Who’s behind this?” in biology. “Who’s behind this?” in government. When the language is consistent, students stop seeing it as one teacher’s thing and start seeing it as just how we think here.
That’s where school librarians come in. Several states are giving librarians a central role in media literacy, and it makes sense. We work with every department, every grade, and every student. We can help teachers find examples, co-teach a lesson, or build a quick activity that fits their content. Most teachers are already teaching some version of critical thinking. We can help connect the dots.
Why This is Hard for Students
Let’s be real: this is hard. Not because teenagers aren’t smart, but because nearly everything about the internet works against them.
The biggest obstacle is confidence. Today’s students grew up online. They know the apps, the trends, and the shortcuts, and that fluency feels like expertise. But being comfortable online isn’t the same as being good at evaluating it. As Sam Wineburg put it when his team released their Nebraska study, most young people are “much more gullible than they think they are.”
The research backs him up, and it’s sobering. In a 2016 Stanford study, 82% of middle schoolers couldn’t tell the difference between a news story and an advertisement. In a 2021 national study of more than 3,400 high schoolers, over half believed an anonymous Facebook video, which was actually shot in Russia, was “strong evidence” of voter fraud in the United States. These aren’t careless kids. They’re doing what feels reasonable in the moment.
Part of the problem is that students judge by what’s easiest to see. The ACRL framework notes that learners often rely on “surface-level indicators of authority,” like the type of publication or the author’s credentials, before they learn to dig deeper. A clean design, a professional logo, and an official-sounding name all look like credibility. To a teenager scrolling fast, they’re indistinguishable from the real thing.
Then there’s the irony that the skills we’ve spent years teaching can get in the way. In English class, I taught students to read closely, stay with the text, and dig into every word. That’s still valuable, but online, close reading can trap you. Lateral reading asks students to do the opposite: leave the page before they’ve even finished it. That feels wrong, and for a lot of students it takes real practice before it becomes instinct.
Even the best instruction has limits. Lateral reading lessons clearly work, but in most studies, plenty of students still miss the mark afterward. And teachers aren’t always equipped to help. Wineburg notes that many teachers don’t feel ready to teach these skills without more training.
None of that is a reason to give up. It’s a reason to stop treating information literacy as a one-time lesson and start treating it as a habit we build every day. And the best way to build that habit is to make students prove it.
What “Proving it” Looks Like
“Prove it” has become one of my favorite phrases in the library. Not as a challenge or a gotcha, but as an invitation. When a student tells me something is true, I want them to be able to show me how they know.
In practice, it starts with one question: How do you know? Where did this claim come from, and why do you trust it? The first few times, students usually shrug and say they saw it somewhere or they “just know”. That’s fine. That’s where we start.
Next, we trace it back. When a student says they got something from TikTok, I don’t shut it down. TikTok is where they saw the claim, not where it came from. So we go looking. Who made the video? Where did they get their information? Is there a study, an article, or an expert behind it, or does the trail just disappear? Sometimes an influencer is citing solid research. Sometimes they’re repeating a rumor. Either way, figuring that out is the lesson.
Then we look for a second source, one that confirms the claim independently, not one that’s just repeating the first. If the only places saying something are all quoting each other, that tells us something too.
Finally, students explain their reasoning out loud or in writing. Not just “this source is reliable,” but why. What did they check? What convinced them? What are they still unsure about?
That last part matters, because how we grade this shapes how students approach it. I tell students plainly: I’m not grading what you believe. I’m grading how well you support it. Two students can land on different conclusions and both do excellent work if their reasoning holds up. That takes the pressure off getting the “right” answer and puts it on thinking clearly, which is the whole point.
And I model it constantly. When I pull up a source in front of a class, I’ll say, “I thought this was reliable, but let’s check.” Sometimes I’m wrong, and I say so. Changing your mind because of evidence isn’t failure. It’s exactly what we want students to learn to do.
Because in the end, information literacy comes down to one question students can carry with them long after they leave our libraries: Who’s behind this?
