The re-trial of the man accused in the Palisades arson fire was on hold Monday morning as the judge looked into whether defense attorneys violated court rules by failing to share documents, expert reports and other material.
Federal prosecutors accused the defense in the second trial of 31-year-old Jonathan Rinderknecht of deliberately withholding the evidence, claiming in court papers filed Sunday that a defense expert witness failed to provide any pre-trial disclosure. U.S. District Court Judge Anne Hwang directed a federal agent to follow the witness to a hotel room last Friday afternoon and copy the material.
The witness, a former U.S. Forest Service fire investigator, testified in both of Rinderknecht’s trials, the first of which ended in a mistrial with jurors deadlocking in favor of acquittal. The prosecution asked the judge to strike, or throw out the witness’ testimony, and block the defense’s next expert who had discussed the case with the witness.
The judge ordered the materials turned over to her and prosecutors for review in an unusual series of events that temporarily derailed the re-trial.
Lead defense attorney Steve Haney denied any wrongdoing during a hearing early Monday morning, and said his expert, Thomas Guzman, had little to disclose in pre-trial discovery, the stage at which attorneys for the defense and prosecution are informed about evidence and witnesses prior to a trial so both sides can prepare their cases and cross-examine witnesses.
The judge has not announced any conclusions related to the prosecution’s claims. She planned to call attorneys back to court once her review of more than 1,000 pages of documents and additional digital evidence is complete.
Rinderknecht faces two federal arson charges in connection with a small brush fire that authorities said was fanned by strong winds days later to become the deadly January 2025 Palisades Fire on the Los Angeles County coast.
Defense attorneys have claimed that the smaller fire, called the Lachman Fire, could have been started by New Year’s Eve fireworks. Haney has said there was insufficient evidence to prove the Lachman Fire was intentionally set and far from conclusive proof that embers reignited in the intense winds a week later.
As the retrial of the suspected arsonist behind the Palisades Fires, federal agents and ATF experts testified how the 2025 wildfire was ignited by underground embers. Eric Leonard reports for the NBC4 News at 4 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 9, 2026.
Defense attorneys have long argued, including during the first trial, that there were witnesses who reported seeing and hearing fireworks around midnight Jan. 1, 2025. Prosecutors have insisted there was not evidence of fireworks starting the Lachman Fire.
The jury in Rinderknecht’s first trial deadlocked 10-2 in favor of an acquittal. Prosecutors immediately announced he would be retried.
Rinderknecht pleaded not guilty to a revised indictment that accuses him of igniting the Lachman Fire, the first of the two fires in Pacific Palisades. Authorities said the Lachman Fire exploded into the Palisades Fire six days after it ignited when powerful Santa Ana winds swept into Southern California on Jan. 7, 2025.
Firefighters initially thought the Lachman Fire had been put out, but it smoldered underground before the windstorm.
The redefined counts separate the arson allegation from the Lachman Fire on Jan. 1 from the devastating Palisades Fire, which burned 23,400 acres and resulted in 12 deaths and the destruction of more than 6,800 structures.
In the first trial in June, the two fires were characterized as a single event. U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang has ruled that there be no reference to the first trial during the retrial.
Federal prosecutors said they believe Rinderknecht intentionally ignited the Lachman Fire around midnight on New Year’s 2025 along a hiking trail in the Palisades highlands neighborhood because he was frustrated with his place in society and harbored particular anger at wealthy people. They described him as a man consumed by anger and loneliness.
Rinderknecht was working as a ride-share driver on the night of the Lachman Fire and had dropped someone off in the Palisades area, prosecutors said. Rinderknecht previously lived in the community, but moved out after a relationship with the person he was living with ended, prosecutors said.
Haney told reporters after a pretrial hearing in October that he expected the retrial to include some new defense evidence, but declined to provide detail.
